Planning the mirage

Lessons for planning education from Abu Dhabi





planning education, uae, gulf, global south, one world planning


Throughout the 1980s planning educators disagreed on the appropriateness of Western planning education for poor countries’ students, and on the question of whether training of students from developing countries should be based on “general principles” or “contextual material specific to poor countries” (Sanyal, 1990, p.8). Today most planning programs in North America (and in the West in general) offer courses in ‘international development’, ‘world cities’, ‘urbanization in the global South’, or closely related topics. However, as ‘the other’ becomes more mainstream in Western planning education, the belief that Western planning education is robust enough to accommodate global differences (the ‘one world’ model of planning education), becomes more entrenched. Further, an unspoken assumption goes unquestioned – that planning curricula, too, just like planning skills, can be transferred internationally. Over the last three decades or so, the advent of the age of interconnected economies and the networked society, has had a profound impact on global trends of development and urbanization. This paper argues that the question of appropriate planning curricula ought to be revisited especially from the perspective of education in developing countries. Scholars educated in the West, who are teaching in developing countries, are in a unique position to assess the utility of bringing Western planning education to less developed parts of the world. This paper is based on the authors’ observations and experiences over seven years, teaching Urban Planning at undergraduate level at a private university in Abu Dhabi. During this period the authors were involved with program design, course design, accreditation and quality assurance, mentorship, along with university service, teaching, and research. The paper evaluates the practices and circumstances of urban planning in UAE and the implications for planning education. It is argued that there is a fundamental disconnect between the profession’s ethics, and the reality of planning practice in the region. This gap has not been considered in depth in either program design or in accreditation standards. The paper concludes with recommendations for planning education in the Gulf region.

How to Cite

Chakravarty, S., & Qamhaieh, A. (2019). Planning the mirage: Lessons for planning education from Abu Dhabi. Transactions of the Association of European Schools of Planning, 3(1), 23–36.







Abramson, Daniel B. (2005) The “Studio Abroad” as a mode of transcultural engagement in urban planning education: A reflection on ten years of Sino-Canadian collaboration. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 25 (1), pp.89-102.

Afshar, Farokh (2001) Preparing planners for a globalizing world: The planning school at the University of Guelph. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 20 (3), pp.339-352.

Amirahmadi, Hooshang (1993) Globalization and planning education. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 20 (5), pp.537-555.

Balassiano, Katia (2011) Tackling “wicked problems” in planning studio courses. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 31 (4), pp.449-460.

Banerjee, Tridib (1985) Environmental design in the developing world: Some thoughts on design education. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 5 (1), pp.28-38.

Beauregard, Robert A. (1995) Edge critics. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 14 (3), pp.163-166.

Burayidi, Michael A. (1993) Dualism and universalism: Competing paradigms in planning education? Journal of Planning Education and Research, 12 (3), pp.223-229.

Campbell, Heather (2012) ‘Planning ethics’ and rediscovering the idea of planning. Planning Theory, 11 (4), pp.379-399.

Caprotti, Federico (2014) Eco-urbanism and the eco-city, or, denying the right to the city? Antipode, 46 (5), pp.1285-1303.

Cavrić, Branko (2011) Evolution of Botswana planning education in light of local and international requirements. Spatium, 25, pp.30-38.

Chakravarty, Surajit (2019) Un-cities: The urbanism of rapidly growing cities in the Gulf Region. In Banerjee, Tridib and Anastasia Loukaitou-Sideris (eds) New companion to urban design. New York: Routledge, pp.83-94.

Chakravarty, Surajit (2017) Buying (into) sustainability: Technocratic environmentalism in Abu Dhabi. In Caprotti, Federico and Li Yu (eds) Sustainable cities in Asia. London: Routledge, pp.135-145.

Chakravarty, Surajit and Abdellatif Qamhaieh (2015) City upgraded: redesigning and disciplining downtown Abu Dhabi. In Lees, Loretta, Hyun, B. Shin and Ernesto Lopez-Morales (eds) Global gentrifications: Uneven development and displacement, Bristol: Policy Press, pp.59-80.

Chakravarty, Surajit, Meera Al Mansoori and Meera Shehadeh (2013) What’s Arabic for charette? Public participation in the Baniyas neighborhood of Abu Dhabi. [Conference paper]. Presented at the 49th ISOCARP conference in Brisbane.

Chettiparamb, Angelique (2006) Bottom-up planning and the future of planning education in India. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 26 (2), pp.185-194.

Christensen, Karen S. (2015) Both process and outcome are essential to planning. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 35 (2), pp.188-198.

Crot, Laurence (2013) Planning for sustainability in non-democratic polities: The case of Masdar City. Urban Studies, 50 (13), pp.2809-2825.

Cugurullo, Federico (2013) How to build a sandcastle: An analysis of the genesis and development of Masdar City. Journal of Urban Technology, 20 (1), pp.23-37.

Dandekar, Hemlata C. (2009) Commentary: A multiuniversity planning studio at the World Planning Congress: An opportunity for international planning education. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 28 (3), pp.382-390.

Davidson, Christopher (2007) The emirates of Abu Dhabi and Dubai: Contrasting roles in the international system. Asian Affairs, 38 (1), pp.33-48.

Davidson, Christopher (2009) Abu Dhabi’s new economy: Oil, investment and domestic development. Middle East Policy, 16 (2), pp.59-79.

Elsheshtawy, Yasser (2008) Cities of sand and fog. In Elsheshtawy, Yasser (ed) The evolving Arab city, London: Routledge, pp.258-304

Fischler, Raphaël (2006) Teaching history to planners. Journal of Planning History, 5 (4), pp.280-288.

Fischler, Raphaël (2012) Fifty theses on urban planning and urban planners. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 32 (1), pp.107-114.

Flyvbjerg, Bent (1996) The dark side of planning: Rationality and ‘realrationalität’. In Mandelbaum, Seymour J., Luigi Mazza and Robert W. Burchell (eds) Explorations in planning theory, New Brunswick: Center for Urban Policy Research Press, pp.383-394.

Friedmann, John (1994) Planning education for the late twentieth century: An initial inquiry. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 14 (1), pp.55-64.

Goldstein, Harvey A., Scott Bollens, Edward Feser and Chistopher Silver (2006) An experiment in the internationalization of planning education: The NEURUS Program. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 25 (4), pp.349-363.

Harris, Kirk E. (2015) Understanding the disposition of urban planning students toward social justice and equity themes. SAGE Open, 5 (3), pp.1-15.

Harvey, David (1978) On planning the ideology of planning. In Burchell, Robert and George Sternlieb (eds) Planning theory in the 1980s. New Brunswick, NJ: CUPR, pp.213-233.

Klopp, Jacqueline, Jonathan Chanin, Peter Ngau and Elliott Sclar (2014) Globalisation and the urban studio: Evaluating an inter-university studio collaboration in Nairobi. International Development Planning Review, 36 (2), pp.205-226.

Kunzmann, Klaus R. (1985) Educating planners in Europe: Trends and requirements-an international perspective. Town Planning Review, 56 (4), pp.442-457.

Lang, Jon (1983) Teaching planning to city planning students. An argument for the studio/workshop approach. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2 (2), pp.122-129.

Lowe, Kate and Renia Ehrenfeucht (2017) Derailed values: Planning education, external funding, and environmental justice in New Orleans rail planning. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 38 (4), pp.477-489.

Martin, Evelyn and Timothy Beatley (1993) Our relationship with the earth: Environmental ethics in planning education. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 12 (2), pp.117-126.

Mohammad, Robina and James D. Sidaway (2012) Spectacular urbanization amidst variegated geographies of globalization: Learning from Abu Dhabi’s trajectory through the lives of South Asian men. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 36 (3), pp.606-627.

Morphet, Janice and Vincent Nadin (1989) Viewpoint: setting the planning agenda for the 1990s: Planning education. Town Planning Review, 60 (4), pp.iii-iv.

Németh, Jeremy and Judith G. Long (2012) Assessing learning outcomes in US planning studio courses. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 32 (4), pp.476-490.

Neuman, Michael (2005) Notes on the uses and scope of city planning theory. Planning Theory, 4 (2), pp.123-145. Odendaal, Nancy (2012) Reality check: Planning education in the African urban century. Cities, 29 (3), pp.174-182.

Peterson, Sarah J. (2006) Priming the historian in all planners. Journal of Planning History, 5 (4), pp.289-300.

Ponzini, Davide (2011) Large scale development projects and star architecture in the absence of democratic politics: The case of Abu Dhabi, UAE. Cities, 28 (3), pp.251-259.

Qamhaieh, Abdellatif and Surajit Chakravarty (2017) Global cities, public transportation and social exclusion: A study of the bus system in Abu Dhabi. Mobilities, 12 (3), pp.462-478.

Sanyal, Bishwapriya (ed) (1990) Breaking the boundaries: A one-world approach to planning education. Plenum Press: New York.

Sanyal, Bishwapriya (1989) Poor countries’ students in rich countries’ universities: possibilities of planning education for the twenty-first century. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 8 (3), pp.139-155.

Sen, Siddhartha, Karen Umemoto, Annette Koh and Vera Zambonelli (2017) Diversity and social justice in planning education: A synthesis of topics, pedagogical approaches, and educational goals in planning syllabi. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 37 (3), pp.347-358.

Sharpley, Richard (2002) The challenges of economic diversification through tourism: The case of Abu Dhabi. International Journal of Tourism Research, 4 (3), pp.221-235.

Sharpley, Richard (2008) Planning for tourism: The case of Dubai. Tourism and Hospitality Planning & Development, 5 (1), pp.13-30.

Thomas, Huw (2012) Values and the planning school. Planning Theory, 11 (4), pp.400-417.

van Horen, Basil, Michael Leaf and Sisira Pinnawala (2004) Localizing a global discipline: Designing new planning programs in Sri Lanka. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 23 (3), pp.255-268.

Watson, Vanessa (2009) Seeing from the South: Refocusing urban planning on the globe’s central urban issues. Urban Studies, 46 (11), pp.2259-2275.

Wildavsky, Aaron (1973) If planning is everything, maybe it’s nothing. Policy Sciences, 4 (2), pp.127-153.