From macro-level policies to microlevel practices

Changing global economic landscapes and the proliferation of middle-class gated communities in Mexico





Gated communities, Mexico, inequality, urban fragmentation, contradictions


In recent decades, gated communities for affluent groups have gained academic attention worldwide. However, in nations with large inequalities such as Mexico, which are also affected by issues of insecurity, corruption, and violence, these enclaves have become more common for middle-income groups. Their existence is usually associated with the search for prestige and exclusivity, along with fear of crime and violence. However, this article focuses on other structural conditions that contribute to the proliferation of these fortified spaces, such as the connections between global economic forces and the changes in national planning, financial, and housing policies since the 1990s. Since then, Mexican peripheries have become more fragmented and disconnected and gated communities have proliferated. This discussion takes place in a context of global polarisation, both in the Global North and South, in which planners have been urged to respond to issues of growing fear, inequality, and violence. This article addresses the contradictions of polarisation, because some Mexicans are defending the right to build walls to protect from insecurity, while there is also social condemnation of the proposed wall by President Trump. The discussion about macro-economic policies in the development of middle-class gated communities in Mexico is helpful in identifying the future risks and challenges that may come from the normalisation of exclusionary places.

How to Cite

Morales, E. R. (2019). From macro-level policies to microlevel practices: Changing global economic landscapes and the proliferation of middle-class gated communities in Mexico. Transactions of the Association of European Schools of Planning, 3(2), 141–154.





Addington, Lynn A. and Callie M. Renisson (2013) Keeping the barbarian outside the gate? Comparing burglary victimization in gated and non-gated communities. Justice Quarterly, 32 (1), pp.168-192.

Álvarez-Rivadulla, María J. (2007) Golden ghettos: Gated communities and class residential segregation in Montevideo, Uruguay (Elsevier, Ed.) Environmental Planning A, 39 (1), pp.47-63.

Atkinson, Rowland (2006) Padding the bunker: Strategies of middle-class disaffiliation and colonisation in the city. Urban Studies, 43 (4), pp.819-832.

Atkinson, Rowland and Oliver Smith (2012) An economy of false securities? An analysis of murders inside gated residential developments in the United States. Crime Media Culture. An International Journal, 8 (2), pp.161-172.

Blandy, Sarah and Diane Lister (2005) Gated communities: (Ne)Gating community development? Housing Studies, 20 (2), pp.287-301.

Borja, Jordi and Zaida Muxi (2003) El espacio público: Ciudad y ciudadanía. Barcelona: Electa.

Borsdorf, Axel and Rodrigo Hidalgo (2010) From polarization to fragmentation: Recent changes in Latin American urbanization. In Lindert, Paul and Otto Verkoren (eds) Decentralized development in Latin America: Experiences in local governance and local development. Utrecht: Springer.

Blakely, Edward J. and Mary G. Snyder (1997) Fortress America: Gated communities in the United States. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Brookings Institution Press.

Cabrales-Barajas, Luis F. and Elia Canosa-Zamora (2001) Segregación residencial y fragmentación urbana: Los fraccionamientos cerrados en Guadalajara. Espiral. Estudios sobre Estado y Sociedad, 7 (20), pp.223-253.

Cabrera-Becerra, Virginia and Juan M. Guerrero-Bazán (2008) La política de suelo en Puebla: La Reserva Territorial Quetzalcóatl-Atlixcáyotl. Fuente de Segregación Socioespacial y Riqueza Selectiva. Puebla: Facultad de Arquitectura / BUAP.

Caldeira, Teresa (2000) City of walls: Crime, segregation and citizenship in Sao Paolo. London: Berkeley University Press.

Constitución Política de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos. Diario Oficial de la Federación 5 de febrero de 1917. Última Reforma DOF 29 de enero de 2016.

Coy, Martin and Martin Pöhler (2002) Gated communities in Latin American megacities: Case studies in Brazil and Argentina. Environmental and Planning B: Planning and Design (29), pp.355-370.

Cséfalvay, Zoltar (2011) Searching for economic rationale behind gated communities: A public choice approach. Urban Studies, 48 (4), pp.749-764.

Cséfalvay, Zoltán and Chris Webster (2012) Gates or no Gates? A cross-European inquiry into the driving forces behind gated communities. Regional Studies, 46 (3), pp.293-308.

Davis, Mike (1998) City of Quartz: Excavating the future in Los Angeles. London: Pimlico.

De la Calle, Luis and Luis Rubio (2012) Mexico: A middle class society – poor no more, developed not yet. Mexico City: CIDAC.

Eibenschutz-Hartman, Roberto and Roberto Goya-Escobedo (2006) Estudio de la integración urbana y social en la expansión reciente de las ciudades en México, 1996-2006: Dimensión, características y soluciones. Mexico City: SEDESOL / UAM Xochimilco.

Fainstein, Susan S. (2010) The just city. Ithaca & London: Cornell University Press.

García-Peralta, Beatriz and Andreas Hofer (2006) Housing for the working class on the periphery of Mexico City: A new version of gated communities. Social Justice. Privatization and Resistance: Contesting Neoliberal Globalization, 33 (3), pp.129-141.

Giglia, Angela (2008) Gated communities in Mexico City. Home Cultures, 5 (1), pp.65-84.

González-Arellano, Salomón and Adriana Larralde-Corona (2019) La forma urbana actual de las zonas metropolitanas en México: Indicadores y Dimensiones Morfológicas. Estudios Demográficos y Urbanos, 34 (100), pp.11-42.

Healey, Patsy (2013) Circuits of knowledge and techniques: The transnational flow of planning ideas and practices. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 37 (5), pp.1510-1526.

Horta-Duarte, Regina (2012) It does not even seem like we are in Brazil: Country clubs and gated communities in Belo Horizonte, Brazil, 1951-1964. Journal of Latin American Studies, 44 (3), pp.435-466.

INEGI (2016) Encuesta Nacional de Ingresos y Gastos de los Hogares (ENIGH). Mexico City: Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía (INEGI).

Janoshka, Michel (2002) El nuevo modelo de la ciudad latinoamericana: Fragmentación y privatización. Eure, 28 (85), pp.11-20.

Jones, Gareth and María Moreno-Carranco (2007) Megaprojects. Beneath the pavement, excess. City, 11 (2), pp.144-164.

Keivani, Ramin and Edmundo Werna (2001) Refocusing the housing debate in developing countries from a pluralist perspective. Habitat International, 25 (2), pp.191-208.

Latinobarómetro and CAF (2013) Informe FichaTécnica 2018. Santiago de Chile: Corporación Latinobarómetro.

López-Calva, Luis and Eduardo Ortiz-Juárez (2013) A vulnerability approach to the definition of the middle class. The Journal of Economic Inequality, 12 (1), pp.23-47.

Low, Setha M. (2001) The Edge and the center: Communities and the discourse of urban fear. American Anthropologist, New Series, 103 (1), pp.45-58.

McKenzie, Evan (2011) Present at the creation: The public administration profession and residential private government. Public Administration Review, 71 (4), pp.543-545.

Manzi, Tony and Bill Smith-Bowers (2005) Gated communities as club goods: Segregation or social cohesion? Housing Studies, 20 (2), pp.345-359.

Marcuse, Peter (1997) The ghetto of exclusion and the fortified enclave: New Patterns in the U.S. American Behavioural Scientist, 44 (3), pp.311-326.

Marcuse, Peter and Ronald Van Kempen (2000) Globalizing cities: A new spatial order? Oxford: Blackwell.

Marcuse, Peter and Ronald Van Kempen (eds) (2002) Of states and cities: The partitioning of urban space. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Milián-Ávila, Guadalupe María and Michel Guenet (2006) Fragmentación socio-espacial y caos urbano: los vecindarios cerrados en la aglomeración de Puebla. In A. M. Séguin (ed) La segregación socio-espacial urbana: Una mirada sobre Puebla, Puerto España, San José y San Salvador. México: FLACSO/GIM/BUAP, pp.109-146.

Milián-Ávila, Guadalupe María and Michel Guenet (2015) Urban Gating in Puebla, Mexico: An SOS for world solidarity and citizen empowerment. In Bagaeen, Samer and Ola Uduku (eds) Beyond Gated Communities. London: Routledge.

Mitchell, Katharyne and Katherine Beckett (2008) Securing the global city: Crime, consulting, risk, and ratings in the production of urban space. Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies, 15 (1), pp.75-99.

Monkkonen, Paavo (2012) Housing finance reform and increasing socioeconomic segregation in Mexico. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 36 (4), pp.757-772.

Morales, Emma (2016) Middle-class gatedness: A practice-based analysis of middle-class communities in Mexico (doctoral dissertation, University of Sheffield).

Moreno-Brid, Juan C., Esteban Pérez-Caldente and Pablo Ruíz-Nápoles (2005) The Washington Consensus: A Latin American perspective fifteen years after. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 27 (2) Winter 2004-2005, pp.345-365.

Parnreiter, Christof (2016) La producción de los espacios de la ciudad global: Planificación estratégica, megaproyectos y las “necesidades” de mercado inmobiliario. Revista de Geografía Norte Grande, 64, pp.151-166.

Puebla, Claudia (2002) Del intervencionismo estatal a las estrategias facilitadoras: cambios en la política de vivienda en México. Mexico City: El Colegio de México.

Roitman, Sonia, Chris Webster and Karina Landma (2010) Methodological frameworks and interdisciplinary research on gated communities. International Planning Studies, 15 (1), p.3-23.

Rodríguez-Chumillas, Isabel and Manuel Mollá Ruíz-Gómez (2003) La vivienda en las urbanizaciones cerradas de Puebla y Toluca. Scripta Nova. Revista Electrónica de Geografía y Ciencias Sociales, 7-146 (119), pp.1-13.

Scheinbaum, Diana (2010) Gated communities in Mexico City: A historical perspective. In Bagaeen, Samer and Ola Uduku (eds) Gated communities: Social sustainability in contemporary and historical gated developments. London: Earthscan.

Segovia, Olga (2007) Espacios públicos y construcción social: Hacia un ejercicio de ciudadanía. Chile: Ediciones Sur.

Shove, Elizabeth, Mika Patzar and Matt Watson (2012) The dynamics of social practice: Everyday life and how it changes. London: SAGE.

The World Bank (1993) Housing: Enabling markets to work. A World Bank Policy Paper with Technical Supplements (K.S. Mayo, ed.). Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.

Vidal, Gregorio, Wesley C. Marshall and Eugenia Correa (2011) Differing effects of the global financial crisis: Why Mexico has been harder hit than other large Latin American countries. Journal of the Society for Latin American Studies (Bulletin of Latin American Research), 30 (4), pp.419-435.

Vilalta, Carlos J. (2011) Fear of crime in gated communities and apartment buildings: A comparison of housing types and a test of theories. House and the Built Environment, 26 (2), pp.107-121.

Wagenaar, Hendrik (2011) Meaning in action: Interpretation and dialogue in policy analysis. New York: Routledge.

Walker, Louise (2013) Walking from the dream: Mexico’s middle class after 1968. Kindle ed. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Williamson, John (1990) What Washington means in policy reform. In Williamson, John (ed) Latin American adjustment: How much has happened? Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics.

Zanetta, Cecilia (2004) The influence of the World Bank on national housing and urban policies: The case of Mexico and Argentina during the 1990s. Wiltshire: Ashgate.