Stuck in the middle

The transition from shelter to housing for refugees in Belgium

Authors

Downloads

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24306/TrAESOP.2020.01.007

Keywords:

Refugee, integration, shelter/reception, housing, path dependency, transition, policy, spatial characteristics

Abstract

Given the increasing number of people seeking refuge in Belgium and across Europe more broadly, it is essential that governments assume responsibility for the integration of refugees into society. An essential aspect of this process is the provision of a durable path from shelter to housing. Choosing a place of residence, and the success in obtaining suitable housing conditions, are factors that significantly shape the integration process. In the context of refugee settlement in Belgium, however, asylum and migration policies to date have been predominantly focused on tackling temporary crises with little consideration paid to long-term integration and housing strategies. Due to separated policy competences (reception at the federal policy level, and housing at the regional level), and the absence of a sense of responsibility from both Flemish (regional) and federal government, voluntary organisations have developed significant roles at the local level in the transition from shelter to housing, and in further housing needs of recognised refugees. Achieving this transition is impeded by capacity problems, discrimination, lack of local social networks, and limited timeframes. Using the concept of path dependency as a theoretical starting point, this article employs qualitative methods to highlight the impact of both asylum policies and the spatial characteristics of reception centres on transitions towards more permanent housing. Recommendations for refugee accommodation are made to enhance the transition from shelter to housing. Finally, it addresses alternative housing projects that are conducive to social integration as well as to the transition of refugees to the regular housing market.

How to Cite

Wyckaert, E., Leinfelder, H., & De Decker, P. . (2020). Stuck in the middle: The transition from shelter to housing for refugees in Belgium. Transactions of the Association of European Schools of Planning, 4(1), 80–94. https://doi.org/10.24306/TrAESOP.2020.01.007

Published

01-06-2020

References

Adam, Francesca C., Carmella Pfaffenbach, Stefanie Föbker, Daniela Imani, Claus-C. Wiegandt and Günther Weiss (2019) “Lost in transition”? Integration of refugees into the local housing market in Germany. Journal of Urban Affairs, pp.1-20.

Ager, Alastair and Alison Strang (2008) Understanding integration: A conceptual framework. Journal of Refugee Studies, 21 (2), pp.166-191.

Aigner, Anita (2018) Housing entry pathways of refugees in Vienna, a city of social housing. Housing Studies, 34 (5), pp.779-803.

Allport, Gordon W. (1954) The nature of prejudice. 1st ed., 2nd print., Cambridge: Addison-Wesley.

Allsopp, Harriet, Hyunji Cho, Camila Cocina and Siyao Liu (2018) Affordable housing policy and practices (Case Studies Review). The Bartlett Development Planning Unit, University College London (UCL).

Balampanidis, Dimitris (2020) Housing pathways of immigrants in the city of Athens: From homelessness to homeownership. Considering Contextual Factors and Human Agency. Housing, Theory and Society, 37 (2), pp.230-250.

Beeckmans, Luce (2017) Wonen in diversiteit: Inclusieve woonvormen voor nieuwkomers. Antwerpen: HEIM in samenwerking met het Vlaams Architectuurinstituut, de Singel Internationale Kunstcampus en het Team Vlaams Bouwmeester, pp.1-11.

Blommaert, Jan, Henk Meert and Karen Stuyck (2004) Van balen tot onthalen: de geografische en discursieve dimensie van attitudes tegenover asielzoekers: casestudies uit Vlaanderen en Brussel.. Gent: Academia Press.

Burgess, Ernest W. (1928) Residential segregation in American Cities. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 140 (1), pp.105-115.

CVGS (2017) Asielstatistieken 2016 (Jaarrapport 2016). Brussels: CVGS.

D’Eer, Louise, Lore Robeyns and Dirk Geldof (2019) Capteren en ontsluiten van goede praktijken inzake werken met vrijwilligers bij woonondersteuning van vluchtelingen, (Onderzoeksrapport in opdracht van het Agentschap Jongerenwelzijn, Vlaamse Overheid), Schaarbeek, Odisee Kenniscentrum Gezinswetenschappen.

Darling, Jonathan (2011) Domopolitics, governmentality and the regulation of asylum accommodation. Political Geography, 30 (5), pp.263-271.

Darling, Jonathan (2016) Asylum in austere times: Instability, privatization and experimentation within the UK asylum dispersal system. Journal of Refugee Studies, 29 (4), pp.483-505.

De Decker, Pascal, Bart Claessens and Bruno Meeuws (2011) Woonpaden in Vlaanderen, Heverlee, Steunpunt Ruimte en Wonen.

Debruyne Pascal (2019) Inburgering en integratie zijn gewoon instrumenten van migratiebeheer geworden. MO*papers, 124.

Esser, Hartmut (1980) Aspects of migration sociology. Assimilation and integration of migrants, ethnic groups, and minorities. An action-theoretical analysis. Darmstadt: Hermann Luchterhand Verlag.

Firang, David (2018) Exploring housing careers among Ghanaians in Toronto, Canada. Housing Studies, 34 (5), pp.868-891.

Fisher, Daniel X.O., Andrew Burridge and Nick Gill (2019) The political mobilities of reporting: Tethering, slickness and asylum control. Mobilities, 14 (5), pp.632-647.

Francis, Jenny and Daniel Hiebert (2014) Shaky foundations: Refugees in Vancouver’s housing market. Canadian Geographer/Le Géographe canadien, 58 (1), pp.63-78.

Hanley, Jill, Adnan Al Mhamied, Janer Cleveland, Oula Hajjar, Ghayda Hassan, Nicole Ives, Rim Khyar and Michaela Hynie (2018) The social networks, social support and social capital of Syrian refugees privately sponsored to settle in Montreal: Indications for employment and housing during their early experiences of integration. Canadian Ethnic Studies Journal, 50 (2), pp.123-149.

Heringa, Aafke, Gideon Bolt and Martin Dijst (2018) Path-dependency in segregation and social networks in the Netherlands. Social & Cultural Geography, 19 (5), pp.668-690.

Lafleur, Jean-Michel and Abdeslam Marfouk (2019) A common home. Migration and development in Belgium, Caritas International.

Loopmans, Maarten, Caroline Minon, Nathalie Perrin and Jacques Teller (2014) Onderzoek van de private huisvestingsmarkt in België in het kader van de Diversiteitsbarometer. In Interfederaal Gelijke Kansen Centrum (ed.) Onderzoek van de private huisvestingsmarkt in België in het kader van de Diversiteitsbarometer. Brussel: Interfederaal Gelijke Kansen Centrum, pp.136-245.

Martiniello, Marco (2013) Immigrant integration and multi- culturalism in Belgium. In Taras, Raymond (ed.), Challenging multiculturalism: European models of diversity. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp.120-137.

Massey, Douglas S. (1985) Ethnic residential segregation - A theoretical synthesis and empirical review. Sociology and Social Research, 69 (3), pp.315-350.

Mayblin, Lucy and James Poppy (2019) Asylum and refugee support in the UK: Civil society filling the gaps? Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 45 (3), pp.375-394.

Moris, Marjan and Maarten Loopmans (2015) Label: ‘allochtoon’, middelen: Beperkt. In De Decker, Pascal (ed.) Woonnood in Vlaanderen: Feiten/mythen/voorstellen. Antwerpen: Maklu, pp.297-310.

Murdie, Robert A. (2002) The housing careers of Polish and Somali newcomers in Toronto’s rental market. Housing Studies, 17 (3), pp.423-443.

Park, Robert E. (1915) The city: Suggestions for the investigation of human behavior in the city environment. American Journal of Sociology, 20 (5), pp.577-612.

Platteau, Eva, Jasmien Beckers, Laurien Coenen, Nele Bossens and Elsa Mescoli (2016) Beleidsevaluatie van de buurtinitiatieven in open opvangcentra voor asielzoekers, (Onderzoeksrapport, KU Leuven Instituut voor de Overheid), Leuven, KU Leuven & University of Liège.

Pleysier, Bob (2011) 25 jaar asielopvang. Sampol, Januari 2011, pp.1-5.

Putnam, Robert (1993) The prosperous community: Social capital and public life. The American Prospect, 13 (spring 1993), pp.35-42.

Quilgars, Deborah and Nicholas Pleace (2016) Housing first and social integration: A realistic aim? Social Inclusion, 4 (4), pp.5-15.

Saeys, Arne, Robin Vandevoordt and Gert Verschraegen (2018) Samenleven in diversiteit: kwalitatief onderzoek naar de perspectieven van vluchtelingen, (Onderzoeksrapport, Centre on Inequality, Poverty, Social Exclusion and the City), Antwerp, University of Antwerp.

San (2016) Syriërs mogen asielcentrum overslaan. De Standaard. Via http://www.standaard.be/cnt/dmf20160810_02419249. [Accessed 30 June, 2018]

Saunders, Doug (2010) Arrival city: How the largest migration in history is reshaping our world. London: Heinemann.

Schrooten, Mieke, Rebecca Thys and Pascal Debruyne (2019) Sociaal schaduwwerk: Over informele spelers in het welzijnslandschap. Brussel: Politeia.

Soenen, Ruth (2006) Het kleine ontmoeten: over het sociale karakter van de stad. Antwerpen: Garant.

Teixeira, Carlos and Julie L. Drolet (2018) Settlement and housing experiences of recent immigrants in small- and mid-sized cities in the interior of British Columbia (Canada). Journal Of Housing And The Built Environment, 33 (1), pp.19-43.

Valentine, Gill (2008) Living with difference: Reflections on geographies of encounter. Progress in Human Geography, 32 (3), pp.323-337.

Van der Horst, Hilje (2006) Living in a reception centre: The search for home in an institutional setting. Housing, Theory and Society, 21 (1), pp.36-46.

Van Kapel, Nienke and Anneloes Nuis (2014) Sociale cohesie in Londen en Bradford: de invloed van lokale community projecten op sociale cohesie in multiculturele wijken. Universiteit van Utrecht.

Vanderbruggen, Maaike (2014) Het migratiebeleid doorgelicht. [Online] Available from: https://www.vluchtelingenwerk. be/sites/default/ les/dossier_migratie.pdf. [Accessed 13 May, 2017].

Vanderslycke, Didier (2016) “Er is wél gebrek aan beleidsplan en hoge woningnood onder erkende vluchtelingen.” [Online] Available from: http://www.dewereldmorgen.be/artikel/2016/03/04/er-is-wel-gebrek-aan-beleidsplan-en-hoge-woningnood-onder-erkende-vluchtelingen. [Accessed 30 June, 2018].

Vandevoordt, Robin (2019) Eroding Rights, Crafting Solidarity? Shifting Dynamics in the State–Civil Society Nexus in Flanders and Brussels. Social Inclusion, 7 (2), pp.106-117.

Vluchtelingenwerk Nederland (2017) Standpunt Opvang. [Online] Available from: https:// www.vluchtelingenwerk.nl/wat-wij-doen/standpunten/standpunt-opvang [Accessed 13 May, 2017].

Vluchtelingenwerk Vlaanderen (2017) Opvang. [Online] Available from: http://www. Vluchtelingenwerk..be/opvang. [Accessed 20 May, 2017].

VVSG (2017) Materiële opvang: Invoering nieuw opvangmodel asielzoekers heropgestart. [Online] Available from: http://www.vvsg.be/sociaal_beleid_en_werk/Vreemdelingen/Pages/materiële_opvang.aspx. [Accessed 13 May, 2017].

Walters, William (2004) Secure borders, safe haven, domopolitics. Citizenship Studies, 8 (3), pp.237-260.

Wyckaert, Elizabeth (2017) My name is not a refugee: Een onderzoek naar vluchtelingen integratie vanuit primaire opvang en huisvesting. Leuven: KU Leuven, Faculteit Architectuur.